Chocolate Chip Cookie: A Gooey Recipe

May 18, 2020 This College Life Staff

Everybody needs a solid chocolate chip cookie recipe on-hand. After looking through a few different cookie recipes around the internet and some experimenting, I arrived at this.

Subscribe to our food YouTube channel!!

The cookie yield from this is about 40, crispy on the outside, and gooey on the inside. No nuts, pretty straightforward, and you probably have most of the ingredients in your pantry to make some right now.

This takes about 2 hours total if you want to make every chocolate chip cookie, or, if you only do 1 sheet of them it’s a little over an hour. The big thing that ends up taking so much time? H

How long you decide to leave the dough in the fridge. This recipe calls for putting the dough in the fridge for an hour.

Half an hour should work, however, to get the desired effect from chilling before baking.

What You Will Need

What It Is	Name	Where To Find
Cookware	3 Bowls, at least 1 glass	Amazon
Cookware	Mixing spatula	Amazon
Cookware	Slotted spatula	Amazon
Cookware	Measuring spoons	Amazon
Cookware	Butter Knife	Amazon
Cookware	Measuring cups	Amazon
Bakeware	Baking Sheet	Amazon
Bakeware	Cooling Rack	Amazon
Bakeware	Parchment Paper	Amazon
Ingredient	1 cup softened butter (2 sticks)	Store
Ingredient	2 cups white sugar	Amazon
Ingredient	2 eggs	Store
Ingredient	2 teaspoons vanilla extract	Amazon
Ingredient	1/2 teaspoon salt	Amazon
Ingredient	3 cups all-purpose flower	Store
Ingredient	2 Cups Toll House Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips	Amazon

Let’s Make It!

sticks of butter for cookie recipe — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Start off by grabbing enough butter for 1 cup. Normally that’s two sticks, but a good cookie needs a healthy amount butter.

stick of butter and bowl for cookie recipe — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Start with one of the sticks.

stick of butter in a bowl — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Unwrap and throw it in the bowl. Or stand it straight up, whatever works for you. Alternatively, you can take the butter sticks out earlier and let them get soft to room temperature instead of doing the microwave method. It didn’t seem like this affected the cookie negatively in any way.

15 seconds on microwave — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

The first time I only did 15 seconds and that wasn’t quite enough.

butter in microwave for cookie recipe — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Thirty seconds is a good amount of time to melt the butter without turning it into molten butter.

spoon with butter — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Use a slightly larger spoon for mixing the butter around. The butter pictured was at 15 seconds, not quite softened enough.

melting butter — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Second try with melting the first stick of butter. 25 more seconds took care of the first one.

melted butter — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Mix that around until it’s nice and creamy butter goop.

melted butter in bowl — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Once the first stick looks like the butter in the bowl above, dump it into one of your mixing bowls. If your mixing bowls are different sizes like ours, use the smaller one.

pouring melted butter into a bowl — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Looks a little like scrambled eggs.

Grab the second stick of butter.

butter in bowl for cookie recipe — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Do the same thing as the first stick, but go with 25 to 35 seconds this time on the microwave.

butter in microwave — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

I’m not sure if that spaceship looking thing in the top of our microwave just appeared there or if someone bought it, but its there.

This second stick got zapped twice in the microwave, so you’re probably best starting with 35 seconds.

mixing butter in a bowl — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Grab the spoon and mix that stick around, too.

pouring butter — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Pour that in with the rest of the butter.

pouring sugar — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Pour the first cup of sugar into the butter mix.

dumping sugar — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Then pour the second cup of sugar in there. Mmmm..sugar cookie.

mixing butter and sugar — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Mix all that around really well.

mixing sugar and butter for cookie recipe — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

It should look like the above consistency when you’re finished.

eggs for chocolate chip cookie recipe — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Get the eggs.

egg — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Take the first egg. Also, this is the reason you’re not supposed to eat raw cookie dough.

egg yolk in bowl for cookie recipe — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Crack the first egg into the bowl.

mixing bowl — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Mix the egg in until you can’t really see it anymore.

cracking an egg — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Crack the second egg on the counter or somewhere suitable for egg cracking.

mixing egg — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Mix that second one around a few times with the spatula.

It should look a bit like apple sauce once it’s done being mixed together.

Now, grab the vanilla extract.

vanilla extract in mix — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

You need 1 teaspoons of this in the recipe.

Pour in the first teaspoon of vanilla extract.

vanilla extract for cookie recipe — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Then pour that one in there.

Then mix that around a little bit. At this point it’s really going full cookie dough.

As tempting as it is to just eat some right now, please don’t.

bowl and measuring spoons — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Make sure it’s been cleaned out first, though.

teaspoon of water — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Put 2 teaspoons of water in the bowl.

20 seconds microwave — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Throw the water in the microwave for about 20 seconds on high heat.

baking soda and teaspoon — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Grab the baking soda for this one. Can’t make a chocolate chip cookie without baking soda!

1 teaspoon baking soda — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Measure out 1 teaspoon of baking soda and dissolve it into the hot water.

dissolving baking soda in hot water — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Don’t be afraid of shaking the bowl around a little.

pouring into bowl — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Once it’s dissolved, pour the water and baking soda in with the wet mix.

baking soda mix — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Looks a little like someone sneezed milk in there. Mix the baking powder around until it’s all together with everything else.

Next, grab some salt.

teaspoon of salt in cookie dough — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Drop a teaspoon of salt into the wet mix.

mixing salt — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Mix the salt around in there.

Go and find a second bowl.

Then grab your bag of all-purpose flour.

Scoop one cup of flour into the empty bowl.

1 cup of flour for chocolate chip cookie dough — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Then toss the second cup of flour in there. Noticing any trends here?

flour in bowl — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Smooth out the flour and get the other bowl of wet mix.

chocolate chip cookie mix — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Pour the wet chocolate chip cookie dough-ish mix into the dry and use the spatula where it’s needed to scrape the bowl.

pouring chocolate chip cookie mixture — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Layer it in there.

mixing chocolate chip cookie dough — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Mix it around and try not to let too much flower spray out the sides of the bowl. Realistically, you’ll probably need to get your hands in there and sort of mix/kneed the dough around yourself since the spatula won’t quite be able to get the job done.

toll house morsels for chocolate chip cookie mix — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

cup of chocolate chips for chocolate chip cookie mix — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Measure out one cup of chocolate chips and pour them in.

Mix the chocolate chips into the chocolate chip cookie dough until they get evenly distributed.

chocolate chip cookie dough mix — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

After you get the cookie dough and chocolate thoroughly mixed together, you’ll be adding a few more chocolate chips.

Pour in the second cup of chocolate chips into the mix.

Mix the second round of chocolate chips into the cookie dough.

Chocolate chip cookie dough — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

After mixing it around thoroughly, cover the bowl with some cling wrap.

chocolate chip cookie dough in refrigerator — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

cold chocolate chip cookie dough — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

About 10 minutes before the cookie dough is ready to come out of the fridge, preheat the oven to 375 degrees F. Once it’s been about an hour (if you’re in a hurry, half an hour will cut it) pull the cookie dough out and set it on the counter.

parchment paper on a baking sheet — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Parchment paper works great, or, just use a non-greased baking pan and lay out about 9 balls of the cookie dough with a tablespoon.

chocolate chip cookie dough recipe — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

It will be a little bit tough to scoop at the beginning (since it’s hardened up by now). An ice cream scoop would also be great for this.

chocolate chip cookie dough on a tray — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Space them out appropriately, too, so they can have room to expand a bit.

Bake your cookies for 12 minutes at 375 degrees Fahrenheit.

They should come out looking something like the ones pictured above.

chocolate chip cookie dough in fridge — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

Put the bowl of dough back in the refrigerator in-between cookie batches to keep it cool.

Let them sit on the rack or your chocolate chip cookie plate for at least 5 minutes before letting anyone dig in. The gooey center may or may not have given me borderline third degree burns when I didn’t let the very first one that came out cool.

Find some milk and enjoy!

chocolate chip cookie plate with a lot of cookies on it — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

chocolate chip cookie stack — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

up close picture of chocolate chip cookie — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

chocolate chip cookie up close shot — If you want to use this image, just credit “This College Life” and include a link to this article.

The Recipe – About 2 hours for every chocolate chip cookie

Soften butter and mix 1 cup of it together with 2 cups white sugar.

Beat in 1 egg at a time, mix it really well before the 2nd egg.

Stir in 1 teaspoons of vanilla extract.

In a separate bowl, dissolve 1 teaspoon of baking soda in 2 teaspoons of hot water. Then, add that to the sugar/butter mixture.

In another bowl (or in the butter one) pour 3 cups of all-purpose flour in there.

Mix the flour and other mixture together. It’ll probably take both hands if you don’t have a Kitchen Aid with a dough hook.

Mix in the chocolate chips, then put them in the refrigerator for an hour.

Preheat oven to 375 and bake 9 cookies at a time on parchment paper for 12 minutes, let them cool for 5 minutes before eating after they come out.

Click Here For Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe Only (no pics)